P2P

30 Feedback completes the cycle. Shadow Leaders thrive when managers highlight contributions that extend beyond the job description and design feedback systems that reward initiative rather than compliance. A manager who says, "You made that project work by pulling the team together," reinforces the message that influence matters as much as authority. Over time, this recognition fuels the Shadow Leader's confidence and strengthens the culture of the entire team. Organizations also face challenges when employing Shadow Leaders. Few employers offer increased pay or benefits without linking them to a promotion into management. That gap creates risk. A 2022 Gallup study found that replacing a professional staff member costs between one-half and two times that employee's annual salary. In 2025, Gallup also reported that pay or benefits ranked as the second most common reason people look for a new job. Together, these findings create a strong case for redesigning compensation. Employers need systems that reward expertise and influence as much as the willingness to accept the formal responsibilities of management. When a skilled contributor leaves, the organization loses more than money. It also loses cultural knowledge, relationships, and expertise that may take years to rebuild. CONCLUSION Shadow Leadership reflects a broader shift in how people think about careers. Many professionals want influence and purpose without the burden of managing others. Organizations that learn to cultivate these leaders will benefit from stronger teams, more resilient cultures, and a deeper bench of talent ready to guide the future. By valuing expertise, trust, and collaboration, employers can keep their best talent engaged and demonstrate that leadership is not just a title, but a practice available to everyone. The future belongs to individuals and organizations that embrace leadership at every level, regardless of title. REX BALBOA is a legal technology leader and writer based in Chicago. He currently serves as Senior Manager of Applications at Vedder Price, where he focuses on driving adoption, innovation, and operational efficiency across the firm's technology stack. Previously, Rex held senior roles at Litera, partnering with law firms around the world to implement solutions for document drafting, transaction management, and data-driven practice optimization.

• Cover